Contact us

UK court: News-clipping service must obtain licenses from newspaper publishers

LONDON (AP) — The British Supreme Court has decided partially in favor of news-clipping service Meltwater in its long-running dispute with UK newspaper publishers, who accused Meltwater of distributing excerpts of stories online without paying any licensing fees.

The country's highest court ruled Wednesday that Meltwater's customers and anyone else in the UK cannot be prosecuted for viewing news stories online. But the court confirmed that Meltwater and its customers must obtain licenses from the newspaper publishers.

The ruling stems from a dispute between Meltwater and the UK's Newspaper Licensing Agency, which represents newspaper publishers. Meltwater provides its customers — mostly public relations firms wanting to track news about their clients — reports that contain hyperlinks, the opening paragraphs of articles and other excerpts via email or its website.

The dispute centered on whether Meltwater's customers were guilty of copyright infringement when they viewed articles online without the explicit consent of the newspapers that provided the original content.

The UK's High Court and Court of Appeals had previously ruled in favor of the Newspaper Licensing Agency. But the Supreme Court overturned those rulings.

"It has never been an infringement of EU or English law to view or read an infringing article in physical form," the court said in its official summary. "Making mere viewing, rather than downloading or printing, the material an infringement could make infringers of millions of ordinary internet users across the EU."

Because copyright issues concerning Web browsing are so important and have international implications, the Supreme Court referred its judgment to the European Union's Court of Justice, which has the authority to uphold the UK decision across all 27 countries in the EU.

"We are very pleased that the Supreme Court overruled the previous rulings of the Court of Appeals and the High Court that the simple act of browsing the Internet could be copyright infringement," Jorn Lyseggen, chief executive of Meltwater, said in a statement.

"This ruling is an important step in modernizing the interpretation of UK copyright law and protects UK Internet users from overreaching copyright collectors," he said.

Andrew Hughes, the Newspaper Licensing Agency's commercial director, said the group was disappointed with the decision, which Hughes said might nudge newspapers to put more material behind paywalls.

"We think news is valuable," he said. "We think people who commercially exploit news should pay."

In the United States, a federal judge recently concluded that Meltwater U.S. Holdings Inc. and its Meltwater News Service essentially resold excerpts of stories from The Associated Press. U.S. District Judge Denise Cote in New York ruled against Meltwater's claims that its use of Web stories drawn from a scan of 162,000 news websites from more than 190 countries was a fair use of copyright-protected material.

Meltwater was founded in 2001 in Oslo, Norway. According to the company's website, it has more than 800 employees working in 55 offices around the world.


武汉| 邻水| 太湖| 正兰旗| 邛崃| 大名| 宜兴| 富源| 行唐| 聊城| 建宁| 庆元| 南岳| 承德县| 乐亭| 梁河| 郧县| 延川| 始兴| 商丘| 酉阳| 昌都| 盐亭| 彰武| 铁干里克| 新平| 稷山| 类乌齐| 柘城| 亳州| 长乐| 绍兴| 浚县| 大柴旦| 安达| 喜德| 商城| 枣强| 屏南| 昌图| 金塔| 南丹| 昌邑| 宁乡| 奈曼旗| 乌拉特中旗| 太原北郊| 泰顺| 寻乌| 万年| 焦作| 拉孜| 额尔古纳| 苏尼特左旗| 大连| 永新| 侯马| 灌阳| 即墨| 桐梓| 硕龙| 太仆寺旗| 龙海| 印江| 遂溪| 开鲁| 铁岭| 盈江| 和平| 漳浦| 玛多| 天镇| 松潘| 杞县| 西丰| 武山| 富裕| 兰溪| 临沧| 平泉| 民丰| 桂东| 道真| 普格| 张家界| 繁昌| 开封| 遵化| 静海| 池州| 紫荆关| 大邑| 平阴| 定南| 丰镇| 温州| 临高| 东乡| 耒阳| 乐昌| 青川| 永福| 甘孜| 崇武| 乌兰| 玛曲| 杨凌| 西盟| 漳州| 额尔古纳| 克东| 普陀| 绥江| 沂源| 长葛| 增城| 兰西| 大安| 吴起| 志丹| 绛县| 峄城| 海兴| 凭祥| 北仑| 威海| 台安| 民权| 集安| 长泰| 满城| 鹤峰| 新竹县| 永署礁| 怀集| 奉贤| 天池| 榆社| 高密| 静乐| 江山| 康乐| 循化| 伊金霍洛旗| 佛爷顶| 沙雅| 玛多| 巴楚| 南丹| 中江| 衡阳县| 宁乡| 甘德| 邱县| 临颍| 海盐| 茶陵| 古田| 崇义| 肥东| 广水| 五道梁| 昆明农试站| 玉树| 临江| 寻乌| 铁干里克| 扎鲁特旗| 赫章| 吴桥| 淅川| 花都| 承德| 泰安| 博爱| 涟水| 南阳| 建德| 丹徒| 吉木萨尔| 茫崖| 科尔沁左翼中旗| 南澳| 三峡| 武功| 和平| 冷湖| 万山| 乌拉特后旗| 龙口| 金溪| 安宁| 辽阳| 孟村| 朱日和| 金堂| 若尔盖| 千里岩| 都匀| 吴县| 滨州| 辛集| 深圳| 皮山| 扶绥| 乌兰乌苏| 伊春| 韦州| 澄迈| 炮台| 彭泽| 泸定| 北辰| 草河口| 惠水| 望谟| 临武| 盱眙| 吐鲁番东坎| 云澳| 三台| 大武口| 如东| 沁源| 常宁| 遵化| 漳平| 田东| 周至| 兴化| 仪陇| 蒙山| 北碚| 綦江| 德钦| 壤塘| 莲花| 西平| 和静| 集贤| 盘县| 肃南| 斋堂| 桐柏| 加格达奇| 德安| 乐亭| 河卡| 永嘉| 潮阳| 白山| 望都| 麦盖提| 广州| 墨江| 陆良| 华容| 新昌| 康县| 磁县| 沧源| 平阳| 阳高| 马山| 湟源| 涠洲岛| 景谷| 交口| 普陀| 泸西| 集贤| 凌源| 深州| 城固| 朝城| 广饶| 广平| 石柱| 建水| 开化| 伊宁| 朱日和| 高碑店| 四平| 潜山| 安图| 京山| 那坡| 玉田| 中牟| 修文| 融安| 黑河| 朝阳| 潞江坝| 凤翔| 山阴| 米脂| 蓟县| 抚州| 阳信| 富川| 秭归| 扎鲁特旗| 深圳| 奇台| 新田| 巴雅尔吐胡硕| 澄迈| 肥城| 溧水| 利川| 白云| 华蓥山| 东沟| 海拉尔| 聊城| 合阳| 宝坻| 清流| 新蔡| 丰南| 宁南| 华阴| 炉霍| 景县| 黟县| 田阳| 锡林高勒| 色达| 江津| 罗子沟| 长阳| 望江| 南丰| 嘉鱼| 申扎| 伊宁| 肇东| 习水| 治多| 东丽| 霍山| 阳城| 开平| 武城| 湘潭| 牡丹江| 建宁| 榆树| 广饶| 托里| 西平| 定海| 湘乡| 九江| 通山| 新郑| 华县| 通什| 广元| 六合| 杭锦旗| 板栏| 临洮| 珊瑚岛| 定南| 太原南郊| 鲁甸| 寿阳| 德令哈| 麻栗坡| 邢台县浆水| 莆田| 定远| 铜陵| 连云港| 六枝| 红安| 高陵| 綦江| 沭阳| 那日图| 牙克石| 桂东| 迭部| 田东| 修武| 台北市| 陶乐| 遮浪| 户县| 察布查尔| 嵩明| 祥云| 昭通| 马祖| 康乐| 沽源| 陇川